Eimer Stahl was featured in both of The American Lawyer’s issues focused on litigation boutiques.
Receiving an Honorable Mention in The American Lawyer’s 2005 Litigation Boutique of the Year issue, Eimer Stahl was among the "little shops of power" celebrated for "laser focus, lower bills, and . . . personal attention." The American Lawyer put it succinctly: "Eimer Stahl resolves sticky cases for big-name clients."
The American Lawyer’s 2009 Litigation Boutique of the Year issue noted the firm’s strong relationships with clients like CITGO Petroleum Corporation, Land O’Lakes, Inc., Honeywell International Inc. subsidiary UOP LLC, and Union Carbide Corporation. CITGO assistant general counsel S. Jeffrey Bednar praised Nate Eimer as "the best attorney I’ve ever worked with. Regardless of the issue, if I have a big problem, he’s the guy I call."
In 2018, Eimer Stahl was named as one of only seven finalists in The American Lawyer's Industry Awards in the category of Best National Boutique/Specialty Litigation Department of the Year.